Sunday, June 25, 2006

Sitting On A Fence With A Political Compass

I’ve never really needed to know where I stand on important issues for a very good reason: I’m usually not to be found standing at all. In fact, I sit very firmly and with great conviction, squarely in the middle of any available fence.

So it was mere curiosity that made me take this quiz when I found a post about it on Annie’s blog. To my horror, I found that the quiz has no place for honourable dissenters or people who decline to hold an opinion. My fence was reduced to a single point on the compass. But there was no way to occupy that point, that still centre of the magnetically volatile political/social compass.

So: if I did not agree, disagree, agree vehemently (or whatever other emphatic qualifier) or disagree vehemently (see above) I had no place in the spectrum of possible opinion that could be held.

Why? How? Whatever happened to I Agree But… or Up To A Point? And what about those of us who can hold several contradictory opinions with no visible discomfort?

I found that I am, like a lot of other people, in the same square with Nelson Mandela and Gandhi; I also appear to tend more towards communism than anarchism (about which I find I am a little unhappy. I like anarchy!). Or so the results say. I say, give me my fence back!

More about this quiz here.

5 comments:

Jabberwock said...

To my horror, I found that the quiz has no place for honourable dissenters or people who decline to hold an opinion.

Completely with you on that. There should have been an "Undecided" option with every question. As it is, I found myself marking "Agree" or "Disagree" for most of the answers (instead of "strongly agree" or "strongly disagree"), and predictably ended up as a Centrist - my dot was almost exactly on the vertical line (though of course in the bottom half of the grid).

Space Bar said...

Jabberwock, in fact, I'm just going to take the quiz again giving radically different answers, or do an inky-pinky-ponky and see waht happens!

Jyothi Kapur Das said...

who be you..? :)

david raphael israel said...

inky pinky ponky poo --
wherever you sit you land in stew
I recently had occasion to make (joking) reference to a (supposed) Society for the Promotion of Neutrality.
It's true, the Coke or Pepsi? quesitonnaire should always have a "neither" box.

cheers,
d.i.

beepbeepitsme said...

RE: Political Compass

What Is Your Political Compass?
http://beepbeepitsme.blogspot.com/2006/08/what-is-your-political-compass.html